Sunday 13 June 2010

Films And Feminism

A personal observation on women's influences in films.

Consider the following shocking fact: although the Academy Awards (Oscar) have recognized the talents of numerous personalities in films for 80 years, it was not until 2010 that the very first female director, Kathryn Bigelow (The Hurt Locker), was awarded a Best Director Oscar. Female directors have been nominated before (e.g. Sofia Coppola, 'Lost In Translation'; Jane Campion, 'The Piano'), but for only 4 times over the last 80 years. For some culturally-related reasons, women tended to be under-represented when looking in this perspective. That may not be true: if you look at it in a mechanistic manner, it will always be ensured that there will be female winners in the award because the Best Actress in Leading Role / Supporting Role awards have always been in the Oscar. What is obvious, however, is that some of the most talented people ever emerged in films are women. 

Kathryn Bigelow


The content of a film can always reflect the contemporary culture at the particular time, thus watching a classic film will definitely give you insights into the history and culture of that particular timeline. The very first lady in film that has inspired us is obviously Scarlett O'Hara (portrayed by the legendary actress Vivien Leigh), in  'Gone With The Wind'. The iconic aspect of this character was her liberal spirit and her tenacity, which was clearly ahead of her time. Her influence has protruded from her elegant look to her spirit, and it should become no surprise that even the male counterparts will be inspired by her. An additional reason for her popularity is obviously the time in question: it was a time when the menacing Great Depression has just passed, and it was this restorative spirit of her that we needed to make ourselves back on track. Leigh's role has clearly stood the test of time, and become an eternal icon in film art.

Vivien Leigh


The Great Depression has also led to the emergence of a sub-category of film - the Film Noir. While this type of film is often realistic and dark in tone, the importance of female characters in these films cannot be underestimated. The element of 'Femme Fatale' has very much become an essential ingredient in all these classics. The role of these ladies is not merely acting as visual sensations. The female characters are used for driving the plot. They unfold the secrets and provide clues to lead us through the maze. Of course, too often they also contribute to the male protagonist’s misfortune. In other cases the ladies can be manipulative. These observations have important cultural implications:  in an age where males have a much higher social status, these vixens illuminate that the males can just be hopelessly vulnerable – bringing a balancing act to the 'battle of the sexes'.

The Big Combo

Lauren Bacall



It's evident that certain treatments of plots will be at a better hand if it is done by a  female writer / director. By this assumption we are looking at the issue at a male’s perspective - which is not particularly biased given the development of film art in general. Indeed, female artists tend to have a very distinctive psyche when it comes to certain sort of topics, and often they are able to shed light on the blind spot where a male cannot perceive. A good example is that, if Jane Eyre is written by a male author instead of Charlotte Bronte, Ms. Eyre will clearly not become an icon. Thus, it may be a bit surprising at first sight that some of the finest films about women are the works of male directors. The most famous contender is obviously Ingmar Bergman, and his 2 master strokes are ‘Cries And Whispers’ and ‘Persona’. The wonderfulness of these 2 masterpieces warrants future accounts of their own, yet the extent of how Bergman understands about women was one of a kind. Bergman loved to talk to women, and he was voraciously interested about ladies. It was this passion that the lasses were happy to share their little secrets to him. Bergman has found his muse in the name of Liv Ullman. This perfect match has led to 10 pieces of great work (including the aforementioned two). The ultimate lesson from this, in particular for an auteur, is that there will be such a gift to have a muse – someone that will inspire you to the point that you are always happy to write stories for them. 

Cries And Whispers


The contemporary favor for girl power originated from a few mainstream films, namely the ‘Alien’ and ‘The Terminator’ series.  These films very much embraced the rising awareness of ‘equal sex’ in the society. The protagonists, Ellen Ripley and Sarah Connor are courageous, intelligent, and independent.  I believe Feminism is amongst one of the key sub-plots , other than human-technology interactions in the ‘Terminator’ series – that represents the evolution of Sarah Connor from a timid woman to a courageous warrior that fights for the future. An interesting observation in the first ‘Alien’ picture was that the director has made no attempts to allow the Ellen Ripley role as a superwoman at the very beginning of the film, she was not seen as a heroine when the film began. The 7 people on the spaceship ‘Nostromo’ was working as a team, and there were clear tensions between Ripley and her male colleagues concerning work practices. It was not until the Alien killed off almost everyone on ‘Nostromo’, at that point that Ripley had to rely on her own. The whole process of Alien once again represented our heroine’s transformation, for which her courage was evident in all the subsequent Alien films. Indeed, the directors behind these 2 famous series, Ridley Scott and James Cameron, both have a strong track record in the portrayal of strong female characters in their films. Scott has obviously made an ultimate Feminist statement, ‘Thelma and Louise’. Indeed, ‘Alien’ and ‘Terminator’ have often been cited as the prime examples of the depiction of Feminism in modern cinema. 

Ellen Ripley (Sigourney Weaver)

Sarah Connor (Linda Hamilton)



In an interview, Jada Pinkett Smith has stated her philosophy of working in a masculine world – don’t be the ‘loudest’ one but have your ‘authentic confidence’. It is this very precious femininity that makes ladies so sexy. The talent that females have contributed to the modern cinema was clearly unquestionable. 


By Ed Law 
13/06/2010

以戲服人 Film Analysis – 0

Saturday 22 May 2010

花邊教主


美國CW電視台潮劇花邊教主(Gossip Girl) 在舉座嘩然下落幕。相信結局不但為GG迷帶來連場OMFG的慘叫外, 連日來亦tweet 爆社交網站。當中最為震撼的, 一定是世界最有名的壞男孩 Chuck Bass 中鎗倒地, 是否已魂歸天國就要等待Season 4 自有分曉。 相信不少討厭 Bass-tard 的觀眾頓時感到大快人心。 E人倒想: Blair Waldorf 怎樣辦? 明顯地, 在這些少女的小圈子(clique), E人早就加入「B隊」。這套被評為是Every Parent's Nightmare的潮劇, 看真一點其實又有不少令人發人深省的地方。現在就放下那道德的假面具…


花邊教主(Gossip Girl)是一個在Blackberry年代才會發生的故事。神秘的 Blogger Gossip Girl’ , 不斷以爆料的形式向紐約Upper East Side 的型男索女送上各種潮聞, 有點像現實世界的Perez Hilton 。當然向Gossip Girl放料的情況也不勝其數。Gossip Girl 是一個另類的傳媒, 與現在如 Facebook, Twitter 那些社交網相映成趣。連串的醜聞就是貫穿整個故事的主要橋段; 然而Gossip Girl最強的戲碼, 一定就是Blair Waldorf Chuck Bass 這對錯對鴛鴦的愛情大悲劇。事實上, Chair (Chuck + Blair) 的故事亦是在三個 Seasons 以來最為consistent的主題。


Blair Waldorf Chuck Bass 相信一定是Gossip Girl 最有趣的兩個角色, 因為他們代表的, 是人性的現實。Serena van der Woodsen Nate Archibald 像是完美的化身, 所以不怎麼特別。 Blair Waldorf 就是 Gossip Girl 最具魅力的人物。 國色天香的她總是懂得作出最高貴典雅的打扮; 她甜美的笑容往往暗藏玄機; 她攻於心計, 抹黑誹謗壞事做盡, 很多人自然會把她和一個 B 字頭的 5-letter word 連在一起, 但這樣看又未免太過膚淺。 她的潑辣源自她內心的insecurity, 或者這就是她自我保護的行為。 由故事所見, 她不但懂得關心她愛的人, 更有一份久違了的正義感。 E人最愛的當然是她那極其獨特的說話方式, tongue-in-cheek 有餘又具原創性: mother-chucker, basstard, basshole, non-judgmental breakfast club 等等… Blair Waldorf 是一個悲劇人物, 她不能像Serena , 凡事唾手可得; 因此,作者要她不能得到她所愛的Nate, 要她與花花公子Chuck Bass 一起。 因為大小姐和壞男孩的戲劇性更強。 Blair Waldorf 是故事中characterization 最好的一個角色, 她心理的複雜性令她成為了一個有血有肉的寫實人物。

她冒最大的險, 就是愛上了Chuck, 但最終竟然慘淡收場。


Chuck Bass 最大的罪, 就是他把女人視為一種 possession (E人想起了舊文「憐愛」) 他或者也把與Blair的一段情視為一場遊戲, 這樣的行為不但不尊重女性, 亦顯得他的幼稚。 他萬萬想不到的是 Blair 根本沒有當他倆的戀情為一場遊戲, Chuck Uncle Jack 的一場角力裡, 她甚至以身犯險, 其深明大義令人為之動容。 但當她知道原來Chuck早就以她為交換酒店的條件時, 她是何等的痛心。 結局的慘淡, 只能用天意弄人來形容: 因為 Blair 的姍姍來遲, Chuck 以為她已死心。他便與同被打進地獄的 Jenny Humphrey 上床 , 更令Little J 失身。悲憤莫名的Blair 再次拒絕 Chuck 的求婚。 他在酒吧流連時為了阻止兩名搶劫者奪去他要送給 Blair 的求婚戒指, 最後中鎗倒地, 生死未卜。Blair Chuck 故事迷人之處, 就在他們是劇中真正愛過的一對。 相信編劇安排兩個比較負面的角色相愛, 是因為這樣才可以帶出他倆隱藏已久的優點。他倆互相的關心, 和為對方所作的英勇行為, 顯現他們美麗的一面。 可能最初他們只是一對惡作劇的伙伴 (Season 1), 到了那iconic Limo Scene, 大家看到的是他倆感情的發展, 他們亦明白到愛情是不用轉彎抹角, 簡單就是完美。 原來, 真愛根本就不應滿佈機關, 3 words, 8 letters 其實一點也不難說出口, 只要你是真心。無論Chuck的結局是如何, E人深信當Blair 知道Chuck 為她的所做後, 一定會原諒他, 因為他最終抓緊他相信的東西了。正如一些網上的評論人說 - a bumpy ride , 他們相愛的過程刺激無比, 令大家都覺得他們必定是螢幕上最具魅力的一對, 實為天作之合。 難怪Blair Chuck : At least we won't be lonely in hell.



棕髮女郎的崛起 The Rise of the Brunette

相信大家會看到 Gossip Girl The O.C. 有很多相像之處 ( 同是Josh Schwartz所監製), 亦為E人帶來一道難題: 究竟 Blake Lively (GG) 還是 Mischa Barton (OC) 漂亮些? 其實現時的青春劇 (Teen dramas / movies), 大都是啟蒙自一些八九十年代的經典作品。1985年的早餐俱樂部Breakfast Club (Blair Waldorf 所說的 non-judgmental breakfast club 的來源 ) ,把年青人分為五種人, 出奇的是這個概念至今還沒有過時。1989年的希德姐妹幫(Heathers) 帶出了學校裏clique (結黨) 的現象, 此片也啟發了由Lindsay Lohan主演的Mean Girls. 事實上,Leighton Meester 演的 Blair Waldorf 與當年由Shannen Doherty 演的棕髮美女 Heather Duke 有幾分相似, characterization亦然: 除了她們都有很重的妒忌心外( 她們都各妒忌一個金髮少女 Serena van der Woodsen / Heather Chandler), 兩人都有 Bulimia的問題和擔心自己的地位不保。不知道是否文化的因素, 金髮女郎在電視和電影裏總是比較看重。 但原來早在21年前, Heathers就已為棕髮女郎的崛起埋下伏筆。 九十年代的Teen Drama 由五個數字所統領: 90210 , 亦使 Shannen Doherty Brenda Walsh 成為了家傳戶曉的角色。2000年後, 輪到The O.C. Gossip Girl, 再創造了這種’Blonde+Brunette 的必潮模式, 此兩劇當然亦深受上述的幾套經典作品所影響。



對物質主義的控訴

Gossip GirlThe O.C. 這些潮劇帶起了青少年的潮流, 引來Fans的爭相模仿。 不過,在把自己的頭set得像Serena, 或把自己打扮得如Blair Bear 般的高貴大小姐的同時, 大家又看不看到作者對這些上等人的暗諷? 即使他們有錢有權有勢, 是不是就代表他們不會遇到一般年青人所要面對的問題? 其實他們的財富,可能會為他們加添更多不必要的困擾! 在此E人的感受是, 這一類故事是要對物質主義作出控訴: 有智慧的觀眾不會因為這些角色的家財萬貫而對他們有所傾慕; 真正能產生共鳴的, 只會是觀眾發現生活中亦有遇過類似性格的人。


E人不認識Gossip Girl, 她當然也沒有爆這些多的料。我們可能永遠不知道Gossip Girl 是誰, E人就絕對不是secret. 最重要的是, you know you love me. XOXO E


^o^ 秋水E 
22/5/2010



Saturday 6 February 2010

八十後的麥田捕手



J.D.沙林傑離去, 沒有帶走的, 是他描繪青年人那種憤世嫉俗的獨特風格。而麥田捕手的戲碼, 就在今天的香港上演。

成年人見到現在的年青人搖旗吶喊狂衝「西環官商俱樂部」的欄王雄姿, 感到很不是味兒。縱然知道自己當年血氣方剛, 擲至遍地「菠蘿」的佳話還能為自己挽回不少面子; 但對今時今日連擲幾隻香蕉也大驚小怪的成年人. 亦不免感到「長江後浪推前浪」。 成年人大抵也有看過麥田捕手這部文學經典, 於是他們就搬字過紙, 大造文章。首先, 他們把這些年青人定義為「八十後」, 企圖一竹篙打一船人。 然後, 他們試圖把麥田捕手的主人公那個激烈亢奮的年青人, 代入這群八十後的身上。 但 Holden Caufield 發了讀者六十年, 是神聖不可侵犯。幸虧沙林傑筆下的主人公是一位unreliable narrator, 滿口「流料」, 為成年人的描繪作出了完美的收筆。成年人覺得八十後雄心壯志, 義憤填膺, 但因為他們人生經驗淺, 往往只被自己的感性思維所操控, 以致橫衝直撞, 在沒有明確的理論基礎下就空喊口號, 印證了沙林傑所烘托的那種teenage angst 。 成年人把八十後定格為「麥田暴手」, 是要點出這些年青人和麥田主人公之間的相像之處: 就是滿腔控訴, 但那些所謂的理想根本是不切實際, 形同虛幻的夢, 甚至跡近妄想。成年人這樣,無非是他們的鴻圖大計一次又一次被年青一代「狂插」, 唯恐小朋友將來不事生只有言傳身教。

成年人機關算盡, 刻意地忽視了Holden迷人之處: 就是他那天真無邪的心。在勢利的目光下,他也許只是一條失學的雞蟲。但他就像國王的新衣裏面那個小朋友, 一次又一次地點出了成年人世界的不濟。成年人唯一的招架方法,就是否定他的觀察, 因為他「未夠班」。 這樣的情景, 不就是在八十後風波上歷史重演嗎? 其實年青人只是利用自己的稚子之心,繪畫出自己想見到的美好將來。即使他們不能像成年人繪出一個個雄圖偉略, 天真的筆觸正正表現出年青人的真心, 和他們對未來的憧憬。不過, 成年人拿起了一枝沾滿墨水的鋼筆, 不斷地把筆尖按在年青人的美夢上深藍色的墨水早就染污了年青人的幻想, 還混和了他們的淚水, 未來的影象就變成了模糊。是不是因為成年人掌握了謀生的標準答案, 目光只會勢利, 還是這就使與銅錢打交道的後遺症? 成年人還忠告這些八十後, 不要再尋覓他們幻想的天堂樂園, 因為那只是死路一條。做人要「精」一點,這才是「識撈」的不二法門。成年人以為自己化身成麥田捕手, 正在營救這些跌下懸崖的八十後小孩子。  意料之外的是,他們把年青人推往反智的思想深淵。


無謂再把年青人定格為八十後: 因為年青人要守護的,是自己對香港的夢想,不可以令它跌下萬劫不復之境。倒不如稱他們為「八十後的麥田捕手」吧!


秋水E 
6/2/2010