Sunday 12 July 2020

Getting Ionic at Miletus




Individuals and places perish throughout the long span of history. Yet if one has made significant contributions to the well-being of humanity, future generations will remember these passengers of time. There was once a city-state in ancient Greece worthy of such attention, as it is now widely acknowledged as the origin of Western thought – Miletus!

Miletus was an ancient Greek city of Ionia, which was the district at the central part of the western coast of Asia Minor. The city-state (polis in Greek) resided on the Aegean coast of Asia Minor. The region of the long-gone Miletus of becomes part of present-day Turkey.




Taken from McKirahan – Philosophy before Socrates (2nd Ed.).
Annotations in red by E. L.



Because of the location near the coastal area, Miletus was active in commercial activities and soon prospered to become a wealthy polis at the 6th century BC. Trading activities were as prominent as cultural activities, knowledge and ideas were exchanged both inside and outside of Miletus. Indeed, the intellectuals from the coastal city-state has learnt a lot from the other civilizations, like Babylonians, Egyptians and Mesopotamians, either through communication of trade or traveling.


If there was a key reason for Miletus to become the origin of Western thought, it was because of the intellectual atmosphere that encouraged discussion and expression of new ideas. The freedom of thought encouraged the thinkers to propose their own viewpoints about nature and practical issues, debated with each other and tolerated the diversity of perspectives.


Thus the philosophers from Miletus - Thales, Anaximander and Anaximenes - were known as 'Milesian philosophers', and with the other thinkers in the Ionia area, they were collectively labeled as 'Ionian philosophers'. The trinity of Milesian philosophers were common in their doctrines of material monism – each of these thinkers proposed a material substance as the origin of all things. That reflected the first philosophers of ancient Greece have been influenced by each other due to location proximity.


The Fate of Miletus

Miletus was an important city-state for ancient Greece, not only due to its rich intellectual heritage, but also due to some political and military conflicts that led to events shaping the history of the Classical Greece era. At far as the 6th century BC, the Persian Empire had a lot of control on a number of Greek city-states. While the Persians assigned a number of tyrants to rule the Greek city-states, the citizens from these polis soon felt a lot of discontent regarding the Persian rule. With the action of two defecting tyrants from Miletus, the people there joined forces with a number of other city-states at the Ionia area, leading to the Ionian Revolt. While the Ionian people met a few initial victories, soon the Persians gained the upper hand and captured Miletus as a result. The Greeks and the Persians would clash a few more times in the following 50 years, and the Ionian Revolt served as the prelude to the Greco-Persian Wars. Eventually the Greeks emerged as the victor after the half-century struggle, entering the golden age of Classical Greece.


Miletus proved to be an strategic city for diplomatic and commercial purposes for the next 1800 years or so. The Turks have taken the city twice, first in the 14th century and second through the fall of Constantinople in 1453, signifying the end of the Byzantine Empire. The Turks and later, the Ottoman Empire, recognized the geographical advantage of Miletus and used that as a harbour to facilitate commercial trade with the nearby European countries. Miletus was abandoned in the 15th century due to severe formation of silt and destruction through erosion. Though the ancient city of Miletus has long gone for 500 years, the fact that it has witnessed the dawn of ἀλήθεια (Aletheia, Greek for 'truth') will continue to leave a lasting impression on the lovers of wisdom. 


by Ed Law 
Conatus Classics